The Omnichannel Paradox: Why More D2C Isn't Always Better
When a brand increases its presence in one channel like DTC, it doesn't necessarily mean overall revenue will grow proportionally. In fact, beyond a certain point, growth in one channel actively cannibalizes revenue from another. This creates the "Omnichannel Paradox" – the counterintuitive reality that maximizing a seemingly more profitable channel can decrease total revenue.
D2C GTM Channel Paradox
Consider this scenario: A footwear brand decides to grow its DTC e-commerce channel from 20% to 60% of total business. The math looks compelling on paper, DTC sales offer higher margins (no wholesale discounts), complete control over the customer experience, and valuable first-party data. But as DTC grows beyond a certain threshold, something unexpected happens:
Retail partners reduce order volumes as they compete more directly with the brand.
Brand awareness suffers without the discovery opportunities of third-party retailers.
Customer acquisition costs increase as the brand must replace the built-in traffic retail partners generate.
Operational complexity grows with increased shipping, returns, and customer service demands.
The brand’s products are replaced by competitors who suddenly enjoy sales growth across all channels.
The result? Despite higher unit economics in DTC, total revenue declines.
At low DTC percentages (0-20%), increasing direct sales complements retail presence, creating a "halo effect" that benefits all channels.
At moderate DTC percentages (20-40%), revenue holds relatively steady as gains in one channel offset losses in another.
At high DTC percentages (40%+), each percentage point gained in DTC takes away disproportionately more revenue from wholesale/retail than it adds.
This creates an inverted U-shaped curve for total revenue, with an optimal mix point that maximizes overall business performance.
Rather than viewing other channels as competitors, see them as serving different purposes:
Wholesale/Retail: Brand discovery, convenience, immediate gratification
DTC E-commerce: Full assortment, brand storytelling, recurring purchases
Marketplaces: Price-sensitive customers, convenience shoppers
Physical Brand Stores: Immersive experiences, customer education
Tomorrow's most successful brands will be those that orchestrate a harmonious omnichannel ecosystem. The brands that master this balancing act will find the sweet spot where each channel reinforces rather than cannibalizes others.
In the omnichannel world, the paradox remains: sometimes less is more, and the whole can be greater than the sum of its parts. DTC isn't dead; it just needs to be a part of a larger omnichannel strategy.
Check it out today and experience the future of local shopping with Locally!
